The Roman Empire: Rise, Fall, and What We Still Get Wrong

For the first two centuries of the Republic, Rome was a regional Italian power fighting for survival. The Gauls sacked the city in 390 BCE (or 387, depending on the chronology). The Samnites in the central Apennines were fought in three exhausting wars stretching from 343 to 290 BCE. Rome expanded by conquest, but also by incorporation — defeated Italian peoples were often given partial or full Roman citizenship, which made the next generation of soldiers Roman legionaries.

The wars against Carthage changed the scale entirely.

The three Punic Wars (264-241, 218-201, 149-146 BCE) were not inevitable. The first started over Sicily; the second was Hannibal Barca's attempt to break Rome's Italian alliances by marching an army over the Alps and winning spectacular battles on Italian soil. At Cannae in 216 BCE, Hannibal encircled and destroyed roughly 50,000 Roman soldiers in a single afternoon — one of the worst defeats in Roman history. The Senate refused to sue for peace. They raised new armies and kept fighting for fifteen years.

Rome won the Second Punic War not because of military genius but because of organizational depth. They could replace casualties that would have ended most ancient states.

By 146 BCE, both Carthage and Corinth had been destroyed, giving Rome control of the western Mediterranean and deep involvement in the Greek-speaking east. The problem: conquest generates wealth, and wealth in the ancient world meant land.

Roman aristocrats used their profits from war to buy up farmland in Italy. The small farmers who had served in the legions came home to find they couldn't compete — slave labor from conquered territories made their farms economically unviable. They sold, drifted to Rome, and formed a landless urban mob.

Tiberius Gracchus, tribune in 133 BCE, proposed redistributing public land to these displaced citizens. The Senate had a senator physically beat him to death in the Assembly. His brother Gaius, tribune ten years later, pursued similar reforms and was killed by a mob organized by his opponents.

The lesson drawn by ambitious men after the Gracchi was clear: the Senate would use violence to protect its interests. The old conventions restraining political competition were breaking down. Within a generation, generals would start bringing their armies into politics.

Marius reformed the legions, allowing landless citizens to enlist with the state supplying equipment. This created armies loyal to their generals — who promised land grants to veterans — rather than to the Republic. Sulla marched on Rome twice. Marius's supporters were killed in proscriptions. Then Sulla marched on Rome again, killed his opponents, and retired.

The machinery was built. Caesar and the civil wars that followed were not the cause of the Republic's death. They were the symptom of a system that had already broken.

The Republic at War: How Conquest Created the Problems That Ended Democracy

// COMMENTS

ON THIS PAGE