Vietnam and Southeast Asia: The Costs of Resistance

# Vietnam and Southeast Asia: The Costs of Resistance

France did not accept decolonization in Indochina the way Britain eventually accepted it in India. The First Indochina War — France against the Viet Minh, from 1946 to 1954 — was a colonial war fought with the full apparatus of the French military and with significant American funding once the Korean War had established the Cold War logic of communist containment as the dominant framework.

Ho Chi Minh's Viet Minh had liberated much of northern Vietnam from Japanese occupation in 1945 and declared independence in Hanoi in September of that year, with Ho quoting the American Declaration of Independence in his speech. The United States, which might have supported Vietnamese independence on anti-colonial grounds, chose instead to support French restoration because France was a critical NATO ally and the Truman administration was not willing to risk French alignment over an Indochinese independence movement with communist leadership.

The war ended at Dien Bien Phu in May 1954, where a Viet Minh force under Vo Nguyen Giap surrounded and besieged a major French garrison in a remote valley, defeating it after 57 days. It was the largest military defeat of a European colonial power by a national liberation movement in the post-war period. France left Indochina. The Geneva Accords established a temporary partition of Vietnam at the 17th parallel, pending elections that were never held.

What followed — the American assumption of the French position in South Vietnam, the escalation to direct American military involvement in the 1960s, and the Second Indochina War that ended in 1975 — was a continuation of the same conflict by different means. Vietnam's independence from France in 1954 did not produce independence in fact; it produced a new form of external involvement that killed millions more.

The Indonesian independence war against the Netherlands (1945–1949), the Malayan Emergency (1948–1960), and the eventual independence of Burma and the Philippines all traced different paths — some violent, some negotiated — but all reflected the same fundamental reality: colonial powers did not leave without pressure, whether that pressure was military, economic, diplomatic, or some combination of all three.

Vietnam and Southeast Asia: The Costs of Resistance

// COMMENTS

ON THIS PAGE