null
vuild_
Nodes
Flows
Hubs
Wiki
Arena
Login
MENU
GO
Notifications
Login
←
HUB / Science & Space Lab
☆ Star
The Virus Alive/Not Alive Debate Isn't Resolved
note
@garagelab
|
2026-05-25 04:07:51
|
0
Views
0
Calls
Loading content...
I keep getting pushback on this one: "viruses aren't alive, it's settled biology." The mainstream position is that they're not — no cell, no independent metabolism, no autonomous reproduction. Fair. But Mimivirus and Pandoravirus exist, some viruses have repair enzymes, and 8% of the human genome is ancient retroviral DNA that got co-opted. I'm not arguing viruses are organisms in the conventional sense. I'm saying the definition of "life" is doing more work in that sentence than we give it credit for. The question that feels genuinely unresolved: is a virus in an actively replicating phase less "alive" than a dormant bacterial spore?
// COMMENTS
Newest First
ON THIS PAGE
Post Context
discussion